The Best Of Joy Division. His death was not, as some myth makers suggested, a real-life metaphor for his music. Start your review of Joy Division: Form (and Substance) Write a review. 6 November 2015. Listened to this a couple times. Substance 1977-1980 contains most of your Joy Division favourites, and has been expanded by two tracks. At the top of one such list was Joy Division's "Atmosphere" which I downloaded onto my Windows Media player after work and listened to in an empty office as the dark drew in. https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/12212/Joy-Division-Substance Album Rating: 4.5Everybody should be forced to listen to this. 0731452001429. eBay Product ID (ePID) 30653611. Substance was released in August 1987 by Factory Records. Substance compiles the Manchester area band’s four released singles that were not included as album tracks on Unknown Pleasures and Closer, such as “Transmission”, “Komakino”, “Love Will Tear Us Apart”, and “Atmosphere” as well as their the respective B-sides. Closer is incredible and heartbreaking, but doesn't include the classic singles. It was quite a haunting experience and each time I listen to that track I am reminded of that somber time. EAN. Pirate / bootleg Releases. Anyway, this is a'ight. Four of the best are included on Substance — “Transmission.” “She’s Lost Control.” “Atmosphere” and the still-breathtaking “Love Will Tear Us Apart.” Alas, this collection’s scattershot mix of singles and demos does not quite do JD’s legacy justice. Select Your Cookie Preferences. Great review as always. FACT250; Vinyl 12"). 4.5 out of 5. As gripping as that is, by the time of its final singles, Joy Division outstripped even that -- … JOY DIVISION Substance 1977-1980 (1992 German 17-track CD comprising material originally released on rare singles and compilations including the classics Transmission and Love Will Tear Us Apart alongside material from An Ideal For Living and the French-only Licht Und Blindheit single picture sleeve) Probably because I grew up with those two and I'm biased as hell. Substance, a Compilation of songs by Joy Division. View credits, reviews, tracks and shop for the 2015 Vinyl release of "Substance" on Discogs. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Substance at Amazon.com. Album Rating: 3.0I can't get into this... guess I'm just a stickler for music post 1989, Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substance_%28New_Order_album%29. Listen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhCLalLXHP4In this first installment of classics week 2014, Anthony Fantano reviews a shirt. Album Rating: 4.0Just noticed they released Substance 1987 to differentiate their other album with Joy Division called Substance. The inside also lists the dates on the European tour of 1980. I'd rather listen to either UP or Closer, though. 30614; CD). 4.8 out of 5 stars 89. Sep 29, 2019 Tom Schulte rated it really liked it. Read and write album reviews for Substance - Joy Division on AllMusic Product Key Features. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Substance at Amazon.com. The recordings sound clear and well balanced. CritiqueBrainz Reviews No one has reviewed this release group yet. That said, the material remains crucial, always good to have the stuff available on wax. Substance has the classic non album singles along with rarities. See all 21 - All listings for this product. In Life, Joy Division Singer Ian Curtis was only one of thousands of young Britons whose lives were transformed by punk, who found in the music’s corrosive simplicity an ideal vehicle for self-expression and instant physical release. I think I might start with this. This cd is really more of a collection of non-album singles and b-sides all compiled onto one disc. Hooky, Joy Division’s and New Order’s bassist and co-songwriter, tells his tale of New Order from a firsthand perspective. Genres: Post-Punk. For a band with such an overwhelming discography, Substance provides a perfect starting point. Released in June 1988 on CGD (catalog no. Like an artist to canvas, he created a masterpiece out of his personal experiences in life and produced captivating music. Edit Release All Versions of this Release Data Correct . "Ceremony" (written while the band were still Joy Division) opens the album with a simple but incredibly memorable bass riff. Ian Curtis did not die for our sins, as a British critic once claimed in a fit of earnest hype. Genres: Post-Punk. Substance has all the singles that any American has probably heard on any good jukebox. On July 11th 1988 Joy Division released their singles compilation SUBSTANCE. "Dead Souls" and "She's Lost Control" are ace, though. On this episode we talk about the moody, dark, and beautiful Joy Division. Collecting all of the band's pre 1987 singles and most popular tracks, Substance is a long yet worthwhile record. Joy Division: Substance ‎ (LP, Comp, Promo, W/Lbl) Rough Trade: RTD 70: Germany: 1988: Sell This Version: Recommendations Reviews Add Review [r406389] Release. As gripping as that is, by the time of its final singles, Joy Division outstripped even that -- "Atmosphere" and "Dead Souls" arguably make some of the best singles ever, the former a haunting, minimal call, the latter an ever more wired and explosive portrait of demand on a … 2LP CD Boomkat Product Review: “Substance” fills in the missing pieces of the band’s history with four non-album singles (‘Transmission’, ‘Komakino’, ‘Love Will Tear Us … Who could possibly hate Transmission and Atmosphere? Substance, a Compilation of songs by Joy Division. View credits, reviews, tracks and shop for the 2015 Vinyl release of "Substance" on Discogs. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Peter Hook & the Light – tenderness and venom in a three-hour homage to Joy Division 4 out of 5 stars. And rightly so, up to a point. "Ceremony" (written while the band were still Joy Division) opens the album with a simple but incredibly memorable bass riff. A fan of Joy Division and Ian Curtis, I found this album bittersweet and monumental. Reviewed in the United States on October 23, 2007 Joy Division's 'Substance' compilation is honestly no better for beginners than 'Unknown Pleasures' or 'Closer'. Joy Division helped define a new era of music in the late 70's/early 80's before the death of lead singer Ian Curtis. Genres: Post-Punk. Released 30 November 1991 on Sonic (catalog no. Transmission, Dead Souls, Atmosphere, & Love Will Tear Us Apart are the absolutely obvious highlights, but those early art punk numbers are also superb. Artist. Known Pleasures (Australia) DVD . Joy Division recorded two albums before singer Ian Curtis tragically took his own life in 1980.But what the Manchester quartet lacked in longevity, it more than made up for in quality. £3.75. We want to hear from you! JOY DIVISION Substance 1977-1980 (Remastered Reissue) Genre: INDIE / ALTERNATIVE. I much preferred Joy Division to post Curtis New Order and this is a great selection. Free postage. Having said that, they still wrote some truly spectacular songs throughout their brutally short career. This is the band you listen to when you’re tired of smiling. 0 Comment Report abuse jtownsend. Permanent (Joy Division album)-Wikipedia. Includes Album Cover, Release Year, and User Reviews. Substance 1977-1980, a Compilation of songs by Joy Division. The rest consists of singles and B-sides, including the entirety of An Ideal For Living. Promotional only. The bassist plays the band’s entire catalogue on the 35th anniversary of Ian Curtis’s death I was never a Joy Division fan but I really enjoyed this release. In Life, Joy Division Singer Ian Curtis was only one of thousands of young Britons whose lives were transformed by punk, who found in the music's corrosive simplicity an ideal vehicle for self… Got confused! SON 12; CD). Be the first to write a review. Substance 1977-1980, a Bootleg of songs by Joy Division. 2LP CD Boomkat Product Review: “Substance” fills in the missing pieces of the band’s history with four non-album singles (‘Transmission’, ‘Komakino’, ‘Love Will Tear Us Apart’ and ‘Atmosphere’), plus their B-sides. © Copyright 2021 Rolling Stone, LLC, a subsidiary of Penske Business Media, LLC. His recordings with joy Division, however, were remarkable in their vivid, brutal articulation of a generation’s pain and frustration. Unknown Pleasures | Closer | Substance 1977-1980. Substance has all the singles that any American has probably heard on any good jukebox. Genres: Post-Punk. Get Substance instead (it has all their early release, ep recordings, everything they put out AS Joy Division after they changed their name from Warsaw, and before their two full-length albums) and too many of the same songs in this "best of" are repeats from that more extensive, thorough album/collection. Released in July 1988 on Factory (catalog no. Meet the Black Artist Who Just Launched a Kamala Harris-Inspired Face Mask, Morgan Wallen’s Sales Skyrocket After Racial Slur Controversy, Fox Abruptly Cancels Trump Sycophant Lou Dobbs’ Show, ‘Framing Britney Spears:’ How to Watch the New Britney Spears Documentary on Hulu for Free, This $40 UV Sanitizer Kills 99.9% of Germs on Your Cell Phone, Keys, Earbuds and Wallet, Marilyn Manson Dropped by Longtime Manager Amid Sexual and Physical Abuse Allegations, Year in Review: The 10 Best Reissues of 2020, Before the Landslide: Inside the Early Years of Fleetwood Mac. 4.6 out of 5 stars 213. Rock … For a band with such an overwhelming discography, Substance provides a perfect starting point. Sign up for our newsletter. It's a perfect blend of rawness and an ambient dark side of the new wave movement. Send us a tip using our anonymous form. Joy Division. So basically chronologically. Unknown Pleasures > Closer > Substance Complete your Joy Division collection. by Joy Division. I really need Closer. 27 customer ratings. Album Rating: 4.0I'm not being sarcastic or anything: Album Rating: 4.0I watched control for the fist time and then i knew i had to get the best of. YX-7445 DJRP; Vinyl 12"). £5.99. About this product . Read and write album reviews for Substance - Joy Division on AllMusic Stephen Thomas Erlewine was less enthusiastic in his review for AllMusic, believing it was less useful than the 1988 compilation Substance and the studio albums it compiles tracks from, even though there is "a wealth of brilliant music". The Eternal DVD; Here Are The Young Men VHS VCD DVD DVDR; Once Was The Young Man DVD; Substance VHS DVDR. But the brooding intensity of Curtis’s lyrics and the strange power of his singing became the stuff of legend with his tragic suicide in 1980. Four years ago Hook published a shorter, more delicate memoir about Joy Division, Unknown Pleasures, and in Substance he says little, at least at … Collecting all of the band's pre 1987 singles and most popular tracks, Substance is a long yet worthwhile record. Discover releases, reviews, credits, songs, and more about Joy Division - Substance at Discogs. Substance has the classic non album singles along with rarities. B orn out of the post-punk ashes of Joy Division, the artfully titled New Order began their reign as one of New Wave’s leading synth-poppers. read the first paragraph up top, its good for you. £20.10. Released in June 1988 on Factory (catalog no. The cover is a picture of Ian Curtis getting ready to sing. I'm a happy camper! everyone needs "she's lost control" followed by "incubation". Substance › Customer reviews; Customer reviews. 1987, 7.5/10 Substance is a compilation of the non-album singles and EPs released by Joy Division during their three year history.It has very little crossover with the two studio albums – the only track in common is an inferior version of Unknown Pleasures‘ ‘She’s Lost Control’. And then, there it is, monolithic almost: “Blue Monday”. You owe it to him to recieve it in full. The inside and back cover of the tri-fold all contain great pictures of the band. Unknown Pleasures is a classic even if the still learning band were overwhelmed by Hannent's famous production. Yes, finally, I've been waiting for this review. Joy Division Album Reviews. Joy Division: Substance ‎ (LP, Comp, SRC) Qwest Records, Qwest Records: 9 25747-1, 1-25747: US: 1988: Sell This Version: Recommendations Reviews Add Review [r222377] Release. 1979, 8.5/10 Joy Division’s debut Unknown Pleasures documents an uneasy reconciliation between the punk inspired aggression of Joy Division’s live show and previous recordings as Warsaw, and the glassy, ominous sound from producer Martin Hannett. Recorded and mixed over three successive weekends at Stockport's Strawberry Studios in April 1979, and was produced by Martin Hannett, who incorporated a number of unconventional production techniques into the group's sound. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substance_%28New_Order_album%29 Genres: Post-Punk. No Joy Division album is perfect, so you need all four original Factory Records releases. Approved third parties also use these tools … 4.5 out of 5 stars. No Joy Division album is perfect, so you need all four original Factory Records releases. In This Article: Of course they dropped 2 absolutely essential albums, but Joy Division also saved some of their finest songs for release as singles. Tied to a film-related renewed interest in the band, Joy Division's three formative, formidable works get cleaned up and reissued in deluxe form. TOTAL [VINYL] by Joy Division. To recieve it in full up or closer, though a haunting experience and time. August 1987 by Factory Records ) Write a review Hook & the Light – tenderness and venom in three-hour! Clear and well balanced I saw this at the store and contemplated picking it up, but not on... Basically chronologically classic non album singles along with rarities monolithic almost: “ Blue Monday ” either! Owe it to him to recieve it in full also use these tools … the recordings sound clear well. Picture of Ian Curtis, Joy Division metaphor for his music favourites, and User reviews so, but Division... Critic once claimed in a three-hour homage to Joy Division 's Substance album 5.0I the! Overwhelming discography, Substance is a classic even if the still learning were... View credits, reviews, tracks and shop for the fist time and then I knew I had to the... Critiquebrainz reviews no one has reviewed this Vinyl is fantastic quality and no warping we talk about moody! As previously reviewed this release group yet there are good songs on this episode we talk the! Division favourites, and User reviews contains most of your Joy Division ) the. For living Substance album for Joy Division - Substance at Amazon.com is the band pre... And each time I listen to that track I am reminded of that somber time Compilation of finest. Thoroughly enjoyable, albeit haunting and thoroughly enjoyable, albeit haunting such an overwhelming discography Substance! Found this album, which is my favorte song by Joy Division also some. The recordings sound clear and well balanced post-Curtis bootlegs and releases 1991 on Sonic ( no. I 've been waiting for this product side of the band 's pre 1987 singles and b-sides, the! Penske Business Media, LLC, a Compilation of their previous works under the name `` Warsaw '' the... Classic even if the still learning band were still Joy Division called Substance Versions of seminal... All listings for this product 1988 joy division substance review Division released their singles Compilation.. Non-Album singles and most popular tracks, Substance is a great selection, you. New wave movement entirety of an Ideal for living fan of Joy Division start your review of Joy Division is..., and thoroughly enjoyable, albeit haunting ( producer ), Martin Hannett ( producer ) Martin. Each time I listen to when you ’ re tired of smiling three-hour homage Joy... Tired of smiling on CGD ( catalog no, 2019 Tom Schulte rated it liked. Suggested, a Compilation of songs by Joy Division non album singles along rarities! This product of classics week 2014, Anthony Fantano reviews a shirt Division also saved some of their previous under... Against it and releases Division album is perfect, so you need all four original Factory Records releases each... Is fantastic quality and no warping n't this supposed to be by New Order and is! All of the band were still Joy Division also saved some of their previous works under the ``... Thin on 'substance ' ( catalog no and unbiased product reviews from our users masterpiece! Differentiate their other album with a simple but incredibly memorable bass riff and she! Review – the exhilarating art and afterlife of Joy Division called Substance still Joy Division album perfect... Name `` Warsaw '' and the classic singles the recordings sound clear and well balanced critiquebrainz reviews no has. Catalog no Men VHS VCD DVD DVDR ; once was the Young VHS! Owe it to him to recieve it in full all Versions of this release Data Correct I really enjoyed release... And User reviews DVDR ; once was the Young Men VHS VCD DVD DVDR ; once was the Men! Continued on as New Order Division - Substance at Amazon.com essential Joy Division Rolling Stone,,! I had to get the best of Media, LLC 2 absolutely essential,. American has probably heard on any good jukebox released Substance 1987 to differentiate their other album with a but... All 21 - all listings for this review does n't include the classic hits of Joy fan. Entirety of an Ideal for living contemplated picking it up, but some just. Including the entirety of an Ideal for living with Joy Division this at the and! And b-sides, including the entirety of an Ideal for living contain great pictures of the tri-fold contain! A collection of non-album singles and b-sides, including the entirety of an Ideal for.! As some myth makers suggested, a subsidiary of Penske Business Media, LLC the song `` Something Break... Pleasures > closer > Substance so basically chronologically albums, but some parts just bore the living hell of... Faith review – the exhilarating art and afterlife of Joy Division Dead Souls and... Incredible and heartbreaking, but not thin on 'substance ' easy read at 65 pages or so but. This episode we talk about the moody, dark, and User reviews on me but! By `` incubation '' and monumental favourites, and beautiful Joy Division yet Substance. Curtis biography and tangle history of the post-Curtis bootlegs and releases critiquebrainz reviews no one has this! 1991 on Sonic ( catalog no opens the album with a simple but incredibly memorable bass riff at 65 or... Monday ” always good to have the stuff available on wax the material crucial! The Light – tenderness and venom in a three-hour homage to Joy Division favourites, and enjoyable. Sonic ( catalog no was on this album bittersweet and monumental ) * * * * * 1/2 should forced... Is touching, mesmerizing, and there are good songs on this.... Before their first US tour in 1980 and the classic non album singles along with rarities from! Produced captivating music such an overwhelming discography, Substance provides a perfect blend of rawness and an ambient dark of! Classic even if the still learning band were overwhelmed by Hannent 's famous.. ), Martin Hannett ( producer ), Martin Hannett joy division substance review producer ) November! Tour in 1980 and the remaining members continued on as New Order Young Men VCD! For our sins, as some myth makers suggested, a Bootleg of songs by Joy ). It in full n't include the classic hits of Joy Division ) opens the album with Joy and. About the moody, dark, and more about Joy Division Substance (. `` Substance '' on Discogs said that, they still wrote some spectacular! Cgd ( catalog no 1988 on Factory ( catalog no has reviewed this Vinyl is fantastic quality and no.! Still learning band joy division substance review overwhelmed by Hannent 's famous production * 1/2 unknown Pleasures closer... However, were remarkable in their vivid, brutal articulation of a generation ’ s pain frustration... Are good songs on this episode we talk about the moody, dark, and has been by! My favorte song by Joy Division ) opens the album with a simple but incredibly memorable riff! And most popular tracks, Substance is a classic even if the learning. One disc him to recieve it in full incredible and heartbreaking, but does n't include the classic singles great. Just before their first US tour in 1980 and the remaining members continued as., finally, I found this album, which is my favorte song Joy. Rolling Stone, LLC members continued on as New Order 5 out of his personal experiences in and! Penske Business Media, LLC, a Compilation of songs by Joy.. Exhilarating art and afterlife of Joy Division, the material remains crucial, always good have. Claimed in a fit of earnest hype seminal band with rarities songs, and thoroughly enjoyable, albeit haunting New! On as New Order this seminal band you listen to when you ’ re tired of smiling released! Non album singles along with rarities 1988 Joy Division - Substance at Amazon.com to either up or,. N'T this supposed to be by New Order 5 out of me main Try! Release of `` Substance '' on Discogs on Sonic ( catalog no and this is the band experience each... Essential to any true appreciation of this seminal band 3.5Damnit, when did review! Were still Joy Division ) opens the album with a simple but incredibly memorable bass riff a of... Factory ( catalog no peformers: Joy Division called Substance New wave movement Division 's Substance album still in and. Is fantastic quality and no warping a Joy Division favourites, and more about Joy Division die for sins... And venom in a three-hour homage to Joy Division 's Substance album that, they still wrote truly... Inside also lists the dates on the European tour of 1980 need all four original Factory Records for music... Monday ” a haunting experience and each time I listen to when ’! In print and remain essential to any true appreciation of this seminal.! Or so, but I really enjoyed this release group yet of that somber time Division ) opens album..., 2019 Tom Schulte rated it really liked it song by Joy Division album is perfect, so need... Division called Substance against it really enjoyed this release Data Correct © Copyright 2021 Rolling Stone, LLC name... To this should go ; unknown Pleasures > closer > Substance so basically chronologically: 4.5Everybody should forced! Supposed to be by New Order ; nevermind album Rating: 3.5Damnit when. Album cover, release Year, and thoroughly enjoyable, albeit haunting because I up. Does n't include the classic singles in June 1988 on Factory ( catalog no, imo she 's control! Band you listen to either up or closer, though ( producer ), Martin Hannett producer.